Sunday, September 19, 2010

Where Can I Buy Koorai Pudavai

Ralph Giordano - a Bösmensch?

In recent weeks, there were hardly any people in Germany whom I had upset me so much about how Thilo Sarrazin and his unspeakable theses. Frequently I was trying to get me to take this opportunity to air it, but this must annoy me about myself, because I had failed to personal convenience, in most cases (except for an exception).
But today I once again burst the collar. The occasion was not this time Sarrazin himself but to his rider, who again - of course in a Springer Journal (where else) - was allowed to spray its venom. What is meant is Ralph Giordano today's article in the World Online: The do-gooders and the dark side of Islam . He is here 10 theses on the argument why he believes Sarrazin is right. I will allow myself here to refute each of these theories or rule to show once more that he does not is right.
  1. Giordano used here a very simple and rather dirty rhetorical trick. He takes a single statement of the other side and makes them as false dar. twisted in its logic is therefore all statements of the other side wrong and all their own statements ergo automatically correct. That this "logical" link is obviously wrong really easily understood by itself
  2. The same trick modified. Here the opposite side of the omission is accused of an act (of course without providing evidence that such failure actually occurs). In addition, emotive terms like "honor killings". Because the other side is obviously not supposed to own all actions are legitimate.
  3. Here is the example of Giordano specific mosque, named after Muslim conquerors. Here I can think of it as an equal counter-examples Charlemagne - Emperor as the representative of the secular power of the Catholic Church, and certainly a great conqueror. Or Queen Elizabeth I - a Sekularisiererin that solidifies the position of the Anglican Church in Great Britain has that has laid the foundation for their conquests, the British Commonwealth and as these are also dark chapters such as acts of piracy. Both were also not exactly known for their tolerance and partnership with other faiths. Nevertheless, as a public worship of these figures (eg Charlemagne) obviously no obstacle.
  4. This is about Aiman Mayzek s statement that sharia is incompatible with the Basic Law. Giordano now of course automatically assume that this statement is fundamentally wrong turn and the German legal system will probably undermined. In fact, this statement can, however, the other around exactly point, namely that of the Central Council of Muslims in Germany, the German Basic Law fully accepted and respected, not the contemporary, less fundamentalist interpretation of Sharia (the laws of Islam) this wiedersprpricht. This interpretation of the statement, I personally consider it much more plausible. If this is not a great example of an active attempt to integrate - and thus a refutation of Sarrazin's thesis that the Muslims wanted to not integrate. That being said, there is the public policy long since even a legal basis for the application of Islamic law in Germany.
  5. The Koran calls to kill infidel and Islam is a unpeaceful / warlike religion. Now he has not put it exactly, because that he would come to the crime of sedition but pretty close. The statement Giordano remains the same. Because to me is the question whether Her Giordano ever seen a glimpse into the Old Testament or anyone who studied closely at the history of the Catholic Church, which is soaked with the blood of "infidels". Mr. Giordano - they pull the beam out of her eye. The hate preachers of Islam do not represent Islam in its entirety - as little as the Inquisition or the views of American Hetzprediger Koran burning for the Christian belief.
  6. The fear of the creeping Islamization will at last be recognized as conduct demographic reality. Here Giorano has exceptionally quite, because in fact, this fear fomented by certain media, a great danger to the public tranquility, fear a similar attack in Germany already are: the end of the 19th and in the first half of the 20th Century. Here was the fear of Judaization of German society through the media and politicians stoked to "finally" someone with a "solution" to this problem presented. Indeed, there was then a significant drop from about 500,000 to only 20,000 Jews in Germany. I wonder if the Hernn Giordano Sarrazin and envision a similar "final solution" to the Islam question.
  7. are Muslims in Germany to their right to freely exercise their religion. What impudence in Turkey as long as there is not the same right. Yes, yes, very Giordano, all right. The German character is supposed to finally heal the world. Or they think you have to in Germany does not comply with the applicable law here and the Muslims here can its religious freedom denied due to the legal situation in Turkey? Sorry, but I will just bad.
  8. said Mr. Giordano, a discussion on certain negative aspects of Islamic culture would not find in Germany. Mr. Giordano - They have in the past 10 years, never read newspapers or even turned on the TV? This statement is simply wrong and pure polemic. And sorry that there are other than their favorite subjects are such as nuclear power, climate change or financial crisis.
  9. Here Giordano throws in just a few terms used to get without giving details on what to have to do with the current discussion about Sarrazin's statements. Particularly noteworthy here, however, the keywords anti-Semitism and nationalism - who's talking here of Jewish genes and the destruction of Germany? That is what Mr. Sarrazin.
  10. Again, the same rhetorical trick as in the beginning - this lump sum is merciless. And what Mr. Giordano said here socio-therapeutic measures? And what action he / she is because before that? The odd suspicion I have indeed already expressed.
  11. (Postsciptum): Mr. Giordano suggests instead headscarves for the women handcuffed the men. All Muslim men in Germany in handcuffs. Is that seriously his contribution to debate on integration. Let's start first with an armband with a crescent on it and a stamp in the passport to - how would it be?
Well, I think my original plan succeeded. So far I see not a single sound Ausage Mr. Giordano is left. If one reads what I Hernn Giordano Views have to say, you'd think I would put him in a right wing drawer. This is not my intention and will, due to its Biograpfie also absurd. However, the more absurd - just because of its Biograrfie - this is it, this drive again repeated. In recent years a convinced communist, and for the Central Council of Jews active - then no doubt a moral authority in Germany - he has now obviously in the wrong track question Islam such that he no longer capable of reasoned debate seems. A truly sad case of age stubbornness.
And this proximity to the radical right is by no means accidental. For many it is not aware but the modern Rechtsradikalsimus has nothing to do with the anti-Jewish slogans of the 3rd Empire. Today's enemy of the radical right is erklährtermassen of Islam, which has led, paradoxically, even to a support of the State of Israel and its Palestinian policy. No doubt there are even right-wing Jews are apparently no more able to learn from the past as members of other nations and peoples.

0 comments:

Post a Comment